Crime & Safety

Medical Examiner Stands By Controversial Suicide Ruling In LA Student's Fourth-Floor Death

The teen's family disputes the finding and says bullying and a classroom altercation led up to his death.

The County of Los Angeles Department of Medical Examiner stands by its determination Wednesday in the death of a 17-year-old Benjamin Franklin High School student Xavier Amaya.
The County of Los Angeles Department of Medical Examiner stands by its determination Wednesday in the death of a 17-year-old Benjamin Franklin High School student Xavier Amaya. (Google Maps)

LOS ANGELES, CA — The County of Los Angeles Department of Medical Examiner stands by its determination Wednesday in the death of a 17-year-old Benjamin Franklin High School student who jumped from a fourth-story balcony following a physical altercation.

The medical examiner announced in a report released Tuesday and obtained by the Los Angeles Times that 17-year-old Xavier Amaya "intentionally jumped" from a fourth-floor balcony on Sept. 30 and died from multiple blunt traumatic injuries. The office's report also found that Amaya had a history of depression.

The announcement came after Xavier Amaya's family and community members at a news conference at 11:30 a.m. Monday outside LAUSD headquarters where they alleged that LAUSD officials did nothing to protect Xavier from known bullying conditions.

Find out what's happening in Los Angelesfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

"I want justice for my son. I want answers," said Lilia Paola Nungaray, Xavier's mother.

The Los Angeles County medical examiner's office initially ruled the death a suicide and the newly released reports confirmed the determination and made public evidence the department considered.

Find out what's happening in Los Angelesfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Students told reporters that Amaya was involved in a brief fight inside a classroom before the fall.

According to investigators with the Los Angeles Police Department, Amaya punched a male student and attempted to forcibly kiss a female student before a substitute teacher intervened. Amaya then ran towards the balcony and jumped from the fourth floor.

Video aired by television news stations showed two students in an altercation before one left the classroom and apparently jumped from the balcony a short time later.

Attorneys representing Xavier's mother alleged this video evidence held LAUSD officials accountable for Xavier's death and filed a claim that was since rejected by LAUSD.

"This kid was concussed and confused. This was not a suicide." said attorney Spencer Lucas.

The Los Angeles Police Department said Oct. 7 that detectives had not identified evidence establishing a connection between bullying allegations and the student's death, while emphasizing the investigation remained ongoing.

At this preliminary stage of the investigation, detectives have not identified evidence establishing a connection between allegations of bullying and the student's death, the department said at the time.

The student's stepmother told CBS2 after the death that he had been bullied regularly at school and was afraid to report it because he feared being punished instead of the bullies.

City News Service