Real Estate
$1.75M Home Sale Sets New Record In Nutley: ‘The Market Responded’
"Buyers are recognizing what Nutley offers."

NUTLEY, NJ — A home in Nutley has sold for a whopping $1.75 million, setting a new record for the township, a real estate firm says.
The NJ Luxury Real Estate Group with SERHANT recently announced the sale of 189 Highfield Lane. The circa-1900 Victorian home – which was fully gutted and rebuilt in 2021 – has five bedrooms, four full bathrooms and one half-bath, with nearly 5,200 square feet of living space. Other features include three-zone climate control and a saltwater pool.
The home was listed on Aug. 12 at $1,799,000 and went under contract in 30 days. Take a peek inside the house and see more photos here.
Find out what's happening in Belleville-Nutleyfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Lisa Turek and Anthony Verducci Jr. represented the sellers, and Susan Maryanski of Keller Williams City Life Realty represented the buyer.
“Nutley has always had homes of real character, and 189 Highfield Lane is one of the finest,” Turek said.
Find out what's happening in Belleville-Nutleyfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
“Our goal was to present it with the same care buyers expect from the most established luxury markets in Essex County, and the market responded,” Turek said.
Verducci said that record sales like 189 Highfield Lane reflect the desirability of the town as much as the house.
“Buyers are recognizing what Nutley offers, and this result sets a new reference point for every homeowner here who is thinking about what their property is worth.”
OTHER MILESTONE HOME SALES IN NUTLEY
The sale surpasses the previous Nutley high-water mark of $1.55 million, which was set in July with the sale of 225 Hillside Avenue.
“This creates a new benchmark that buyers, sellers and appraisers all pay attention to,” wrote Rubino Ryder, which represented the seller.
“That doesn't mean every home suddenly becomes worth more,” the firm explained. “But it can influence how the market views similar homes, especially larger homes and properties with comparable features. Over time, benchmark sales help shape buyer expectations and establish new price points for the homes that follow.”
Another local benchmark was set in 2024, when 57 High Street sold for $1.3 million – the highest-ever sale in Nutley at that time.
“This sale wasn’t just a win for our team; it was a win for the Nutley community, as it highlighted the hidden gems that this town has to offer,” Matthew De Fede of Realty Executives wrote.
Send local news tips and correction requests to eric.kiefer@patch.com. Learn more about advertising on Patch here. Find out how to post announcements or events to your local Patch site.