Politics & Government

Dublin Weighs Data Center Ban, New Zoning Regulations

City staff said data centers would likely struggle to meet existing zoning rules as other Bay Area cities move to restrict them.

DUBLIN, CA — The Dublin City Council will consider whether to ban data centers or establish regulations allowing them at its Tuesday meeting, after staff concluded that data centers would likely have difficulty complying with existing zoning and planning rules.

On Sept. 1, the council requested staff prepare a discussion regarding zoning regulations for data centers, facilities for storing and distributing large amounts of electronic data that have become a hot button issue across the country. There are currently more than 200 active data centers in California, more than any other state besides Texas and Virginia, according to the California Energy Commission.

While data centers could potentially bring in millions of dollars in property taxes, sales taxes, and franchise fees, they can also produce noise, air pollution, increased costs in energy and water, and aesthetic damage that could reduce property values and quality of life. They also produce numerous temporary construction jobs but relatively few permanent positions according to the city staff report.

Find out what's happening in Dublinfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

The Dublin Zoning Ordinance does not specifically include data centers as a permitted, conditionally permitted, or prohibited use. According to the Dublin Municipal Code, if the proposed land use is not specifically included in the Zoning Ordinance, the use is not allowed, unless the community development director determines that their operations are compatible with permitted uses, consistent with city planning policies and appropriate for the zoning district.

Dublin city staff said that a data center could potentially fit within the General Plan land use designations of “Industrial Park” or “Business Park/Industrial.” However, any development would need to comply with the established “no nuisance” standards related to emissions, noise, dust, glare, and odor. The General Plan also has several policies directed toward promoting energy conservation and efficiency in new and existing buildings.

Find out what's happening in Dublinfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Staff also said that the General Plan of the industrial Fallon East Economic Development Zone emphasizes employment-generating uses and other economic development priorities, which staff do not believe are consistent with data centers.

“Although Dublin does not expressly prohibit data centers, a typical data center would likely have difficulty complying with the City’s existing General Plan and zoning regulations. Because the current regulations do not directly address this use, how a proposal would be evaluated is uncertain for both applicants and the community,” staff said.

Nearby, cities like Oakland and San Francisco have adopted moratoriums. Hayward, which already has three operating data centers and another under construction, has directed staff to examine impacts on natural resources, or consider stricter regulations or an outright ban.

While Pleasanton has no identified data centers or dedicated zoning standards for them, Livermore has computing facilities at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, but no distinct municipal data center regulations.

See here for more information, and here for Tuesday’s full agenda.

Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.