Community Corner
John Wayne Will Not Join OC Hall Of Fame Over Racial Comments After Failed Vote
Representatives from the NAACP pushed the board to reject Wayne, citing comments the actor made in a Playboy magazine in 1971.
ORANGE COUNTY, CA — An effort to induct John Wayne into the Orange County Hall of Fame fell short by one vote Tuesday at a meeting of the county's Board of Supervisors.
The vote ended in a 2-2 tie, with Board Chairman Doug Chaffee abstaining. Supervisors Don Wagner and Janet Nguyen voted for Wayne's induction but Board Vice Chair Katrina Foley and Supervisor Vicente Sarmiento opposed it.
The board approved nine other inductees to the Hall of Fame, which was established three years ago. The new inductees are Arnold Beckman, Ann Meyers Drysdale, Walter Ehlers, Frank Garcia, Dexter Holland, Tony Lam, Justice Eileen Moore, Frank and Joan Randall, and Alberto and David Vargas.
Find out what's happening in Orange Countyfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Representatives from the NAACP pushed the board to reject Wayne, citing comments the legendary actor made about Blacks in a Playboy magazine article in May 1971.
"With a lot of Blacks, there's quite a bit of resentment along with their dissent, and possibly rightfully so. But we can't all of a sudden get down on our knees and turn everything over to the leadership of the Blacks," Wayne said in the 1971 interview.
Find out what's happening in Orange Countyfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
"I believe in white supremacy until the blacks are educated to a point of responsibility. I don't believe in giving authority and positions of leadership and judgment to irresponsible people."
Wayne was also unapologetic in the interview about Native Americans.
"I don't feel we did wrong in taking this great country away from them, if that's what you're asking. Our so-called stealing of this country from them was just a matter of survival. There were great numbers of people who needed new land, and the Indians were selfishly trying to keep it for themselves," he said.
Wagner made an impassioned argument for Wayne, saying the actor, who lived in Newport Beach, established a legacy of representing American values despite his world view reflected in the interview.
"Certainly, John Wayne's legacy writ large is not what you find in a Playboy magazine article where John Wayne's comments definitely clang off the modern ear," Wagner said.
"To even suggest John Wayne was racist and a white supremacist is a little off given his history, especially if you take out that one admittedly disturbing Playboy article. The man was married multiple times to minority women."
Wagner said he supported efforts to take down statues of Confederate Civil War figures such as Robert E. Lee, Stonewall Jackson or Jefferson Davis.
"They failed the test of having a commitment to the values of society," Wagner said.
But, he argued, litmus tests on political correctness have gone too far with criticism of Presidents George Washington or Abraham Lincoln. Wagner said that "despite the Emancipation Proclamation ... Lincoln used Blacks worse than any remarks by John Wayne."
Wagner said if historical figures are judged by Tuesday's standards, "nobody is going to pass the test, certainly not John Wayne, but also Martin Luther King, who was apparently unfaithful to his wife. And don't get me started on the Kennedy brothers."
Wagner added that "we have rightly recognized what Cesar Chavez did for our society though we now know he was an imperfect human being," referring to the recently documented sexual assault allegations against the labor leader.
"That was a very tough thing to hear," Sarmiento responded, apologizing to the public.
"I've never really cared about this Hall of Fame thing," Sarmiento added. "We're not scrambling to find people" for induction. "But to find someone with such a checkered past? There is a chronicled, documented history of this person's comments and approaches to women to people of color, who are LGBTQ," Sarmiento said. "You can't cleanse that by marrying someone who is a person of color ... That is a very, very wrong argument to make."
Sarmiento said he has never read the Playboy article, but he said there are other reports to show a pattern.
"Every time I go to John Wayne Airport I cringe when I see that statue" of Wayne, Sarmiento said. "I certainly think we can do better," he said, adding he would like to see housing rights activist Dorothy Mulkey honored.
Supervisor Janet Nguyen railed against any suggestion that she is racist.
"What is offensive to me is questioning my character and calling me a racist," Nguyen said, adding she was just supporting her fellow supervisor's recommendation. "You don't get to call me a racist because I supported a colleague's nomination."
Nguyen said when she came to Orange County in the 1980s, "most people from Jerry Brown to Joe Biden didn't want to bring refugees to this country, so don't stand here and say I'm racist because of a nomination."
Foley said the Hall of Fame should not just honor "professional accomplishments, but also the values of inclusion, respect and diversity. This is what Orange County is all about."
She said the selection process for nominees "definitely needs reform."
Foley said that "comparisons to world leaders (for Wayne) like Abraham Lincoln is nonsensical. He was an actor... and his racist, homophobic, misogynist views were quite well known, and his personal life is separate and apart from the actor and the characters he portrayed."
Chaffee demurred, saying: "I don't want to be the deciding vote."
Chaffee said he found "the comments pretty offensive" in Wayne's interview. "So I'm very torn between recognizing those who would like to honor him and the unfortunate comments that were made, so I'm going to abstain."
The Hall of Fame ceremony will be Dec. 8 at the county board's meeting room in Santa Ana.
Beckman was a chemist and inventor and is known for creating the philanthropic Arnold and Mabel Beckman Foundation.
Meyers Drysdale was selected to the Naismith Basketball Hall of Fame for being a four-time All-American at UCLA.
Ehlers was a World War II hero who earned a Medal of Honor at D-Day and served for many years on the Buena Park parks and recreation commission.
Garcia is a restaurateur known for his annual We Give Thanks Thanksgiving dinner for the needy.
Holland co-founded punk band the Offspring and also has a hot sauce company based in Huntington Beach in addition to a doctorate in molecular biology.
Lam is the first Vietnamese American elected to public office in the country and a main figure behind the thriving Little Saigon community.
Moore is a retired Superior Court judge and Appellate Court justice.
The Randalls are philanthropists known for a $50 million gift to protect Banning Ranch.
Alberto and David Vargas are known for their business Suavecito Pomade, a grooming company in Santa Ana.