Politics & Government

La Grange Historic Building Teardown Starts, Surprising Neighbor

A neighbor and the village disagree over whether a judge's order barring the demolition applies.

https://patch.com/img/cdn20/users/23697275/20261116/020312/styles/patch_image/public/jackson-square-demoltion2-la-grange___16135358497.jpg
The demolition of the old Jackson Square antique mall building started Monday. A neighbor said a court order barring the teardown had not been lifted. (David Giuliani/Patch)

LA GRANGE, IL – Demolition of the old Jackson Square antique mall building began Monday morning, surprising a neighbor who has fought the project.

In May, neighbor Jonathan Robinson obtained a Cook County judge's temporary restraining order prohibiting the teardown at 112 E. Burlington Ave. He said the court had not lifted it.

The developer said it has the legal right to proceed.

Find out what's happening in La Grangefor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Shortly after the teardown started, Robinson said his lawyer filed a motion to stop the project. He said he called the police, who he said told him the temporary restraining order had been lifted.

In response to a Patch inquiry, Village Manager Jack Knight said the court's recent order dismissed the developer, Five South Six, as a defendant in Robinson's lawsuit. The village remained a defendant.

Find out what's happening in La Grangefor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Robinson disagreed with Knight's reasoning.

"That ruling did not change the (temporary restraining order) at all," Robinson said in an email. "Just because (the developer is) not in the lawsuit doesn't mean they can't be restrained."

For example, a bank can be restrained from moving money, even if the bank did nothing wrong and is not part of a lawsuit, Robinson said.

Earlier on Monday morning, Robinson spoke with Patch in his backyard as a backhoe could be seen in the background. Robinson was putting up cameras to keep an eye on the work.

La Grange resident Jonathan Robinson works on camera equipment in his backyard Monday. He said he wants to keep track of the next-door demolition project. (David Giuliani/Patch)

The back of the Jackson Square building touches Robinson's backyard boundary. He said the developer apparently plans to demolish that part of the structure without going onto his yard. A structural engineer, Robinson said he had no idea how the developer would accomplish that.

"This is so blatant," he said.

In an email to Patch, Dan Spain of developer Five South Six said no pending claims exist against him.

"(E)ven if there were a valid claim against Five South Six, which there is not, our right to demolish the existing buildings is governed by a separate Village ordinance that has not been challenged in this litigation," Spain said. "The ordinance being challenged relates to what can be constructed on the property, not our legal right to demolish the existing structures."

He added, "We have worked closely with our legal counsel throughout this process and are confident in our legal right to proceed."

Spain said his attorney has requested multiple times to temporarily install protective fencing on a portion of Robinson's property, but has yet to hear back.

"This would provide our union demolition contractor with additional access and flexibility when removing the existing one-story structure along the shared property line," he said.

On Saturday, Robinson said he received a notice that the developer had a certified letter for him. But he said he was gone when the mail carrier came around. The manager of a neighboring condo building alerted him later in the weekend that the teardown was about to start.

Spain, a La Grange Park resident, plans to build a 39-unit, five-story condo complex.

In his lawsuit, Robinson alleged the village failed to adhere to minimal setbacks and loading space requirements.

He also contended the village failed to give him a "meaningful opportunity" to say how the proposed complex would pose a hardship on his property.

The village maintained it followed the law.

In January, the Village Board voted unanimously for the teardown and condo complex. Many residents objected to demolishing the historic building.

Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.