Crime & Safety

North Shore Camera Debate: Beverly Lets Flock Contract Expire, Salem Trials New Vendor

North Shore cities and towns continue to grapple with automated license plate reader backlash amid potential public safety benefits.

BEVERLY, MA — The debate over Flock traffic cameras, and larger questions about automated license plate readers in general, continues with one North Shore city allowing its Flock contract to expire while another former Flock client is testing out a new ALPR system vendor.

After months of public discussion on Flock cameras — including an open City Council debate and additional City Council committee public forum last month — a Beverly Mayor's Office spokesperson told Patch the city was "choosing to let the current contract lapse while we spend more time figuring out the outstanding details."

Mayor Mike Cahill had told the community forum last month that the contract was set for renewal on Nov. 13.

Find out what's happening in Beverlyfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

A message to the Beverly Police Department about whether the four cameras in the city were currently still operational had not received a response as of early Tuesday afternoon.

"More information will be forthcoming in the coming weeks," the Beverly Mayor's Office spokesperson said.

Find out what's happening in Beverlyfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Meanwhile, in Salem, where Mayor Dominick Pangallo said this summer that its Flock contract would not be renewed, Pangallo told Patch on Tuesday that the Flock cameras had been subsequently removed after the contract expiration and, at least temporarily, replaced with a new system.

"Salem PD is in the middle of a trial with a different LPR vendor, OdinEye, as we evaluate potential alternative systems," Pangallo told Patch.

The potential abuse of Flock and other ALPR data has been an increasingly divisive issue across the state in recent months — with some North Shore residents raising concerns about how federal agencies such as ICE could obtain that information and use it for immigration enforcement, and mounting cases of audits showing that police personnel accessed that information and used it to surveil residents for personal reasons.

But as more than a dozen Beverly residents voiced concerns of abuse and the creation of a "surveillance state" during last month's forum, Lynn police late last month credited Flock cameras for helping find a 6-year-old who was in a car when it was stolen in the city.

Lynn police said the vehicle was stolen with the child inside at about 4:30 p.m. and tracked down with the child safe and sound inside in Everett just 39 minutes later using the Flock technology.

Police said the incident "highlights the critical role of modern investigative technology, rapid information sharing, and interagency cooperation in protecting the community."

At the Beverly Committee on Legal Affairs and Public Services meeting last month, all 15 resident speakers spoke out against the use of Flock — or any other vendor — cameras to track drivers, while Police Chief John LeLacheur countered that the ALPR systems have been vital in solving crimes and safely finding those in potential danger in recent months.

LeLacheur noted at that meeting that there is "no expectation of privacy" for anyone when they are in public and equated the Flock system to the legal right of law enforcement to run anyone's license plate — which is property of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts — for any reason at any time.

LeLacheur allowed that there have been accusations of officers across the country and the state abusing the system to track residents for personal reasons. But he said there are safeguards in place to detect and act upon anyone who might attempt to do that in Beverly.

"If I found an officer who was misusing the plates, I can tell everyone here, I can tell the Council, they would not be working for the Beverly Police Department," LeLacheur said.

Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.