Crime & Safety
Judge To Allenstown Rape Suspect Requesting Bail: ‘That’s Very Unlikely To Happen’: Follow-Up
Brian David Duval is facing aggravated felonious sexual assault, gun threat, and strangulation charges after incidents in 2025 and 2026.

CONCORD, NH — A rape and strangulation suspect from Allenstown, who is facing a slew of other charges, has decided to fight some of his charges after a plea deal was floated earlier this year.
Brian David Duval, 47, of Lafayette Street in Allenstown, faces three sets of charges after three separate incidents during the past two years. The first round of charges were after incidents in Allenstown on Jan. 30: domestic violence-criminal threat-deadly weapon, two second-degree assault-domestic violence-strangulation, and three domestic violence-simple assault charges. Eight more charges were filed later: witness tampering from an incident on Feb. 11 and seven stalking charges from Feb. 5, Feb. 17, March 3, March 10, March 17, and April 26. In the third set of charges, Duval was charged with aggravated felonious sexual assault after an incident in August 2025; second-degree assault-domestic violence-strangulation, and two domestic violence-simple assault charges after incidents on Sept. 15, 2025; and second-degree assault-domestic violence-strangulation, and two domestic violence-simple assault charges after incidents on Dec. 26, 2025, in Allenstown.
After Duval was arraigned on the first charges in February, he was held without bail.
Find out what's happening in Concordfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
A week later, more charges were boundover to superior court.
Records were also sealed. Duval was first indicted on strangulation, threat, and witness tampering charges and then, in mid-July, on rape, strangulation, an attempted strangulation, and threat charges.
Find out what's happening in Concordfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
According to court paperwork, the complainant accused Duval of striking and choking her after an argument in late January. She also accused him of pushing her to the ground and punching her in the ribs.
An officer noted injuries to the woman’s face.
She also accused him of threatening her with a gun and saying, “Do you want to die tonight?” and “The kids will wake up to no mother tomorrow,” while loading a magazine into the firearm, according to court paperwork.
Police went to speak with Duval, who reportedly agreed there was an argument and admitted to owning a firearm, documents stated. He was arrested and held on preventative detention at the Merrimack County Jail.
On Feb. 11, Allenstown police received an anonymous tip accusing Duval of calling the victim from jail.
A lieutenant obtained recordings of the calls, made to the victim on Feb. 5, requesting she drop the charges so that he could get out of jail, claiming the injuries did not come from him strangling her but came from “rough sex,” a court order stated.
“After further investigation,” the court doc said, “the (jail) discovered that the defendant had contacted (the victim) five times through email, 91 times by phone call, and 5,721 times by text message between February 2 and March 26.”
Duval was held for months as the first two sets of charges worked their way through court.
Editor’s note: This post is based on information provided by the Merrimack County Superior Court and does not constitute a conviction. This link explains how to request the removal of a name from New Hampshire Patch police reports.
A bail hearing was held on April 16, and Judge John Kissinger denied bail.
“The court is particularly troubled by the allegation the defendant has had many contacts with the protected party by text and phone calls despite the clear language in the bail order that he was to have no contact with her,” he wrote. “He was warned that any additional contact will be viewed as very aggravating in terms of any ultimate resolution of these matters.”
In late May, the prosecution filed a motion to consolidate the assault and threat charges with the stalking and witness tampering charges into one case.
The prosecution noted, in the stalking and tampering case, the communication ranged from “arguments about previous romantic partners, to sexually charged messages, to ‘love-bombing,’ to blaming her for being in jail, to counting the number of days he’s been in jail,” according to the filing.
The defense, however, rejected the motion because they were not connected to a single episode. The filing said the argument stemmed from the victim flushing Duval’s ex-wife’s car key down the toilet the prior week. He also accused her of drinking and kicking him in the knee. Duval also accused the victim of grabbing a rolling pin and approaching him with it, which led to him defending himself, the filing said.
In mid-June, it appeared that there would be a plea for three of the charges: stalking, second-degree assault, and witness tampering. Duval agreed, via his attorney, Vanessa Gelinas, to a three-and-a-half-to-seven-year sentence, stand committed, with suspended prison and jail time, according to documents.
At the time, for two of the three sets of charges, a trial was scheduled to begin in mid-August.
But two days after agreeing to the plea, he was told by J. Garrett Tynes, the prosecutor, that more charges, including the rape and more second-degree and simple assault charges, were coming.
Duval then pulled the plea.
In late August, Kissinger agreed to consolidate the first two sets of charges into one trial.
In court in late September, the prosecution and defense tried to find trial dates that worked for both sides after Duval filed a waiver for a speedy trial. Along with the clerk, officials said the case would not be considered until April 2027.
Kissinger asked if Gelinas wanted to speak to her client about the timeline. Duval said they did not need to speak.
“I don’t want to be incarcerated until April, and then trial,” Duval said. “If you want to give me bail, so I can fight this from the outside, then I’ll agree to April.”
“That’s very unlikely to happen, so…” Kissinger said.
During a discussion with his attorney, Duval said he wanted bail and to be enrolled in pretrial services. Kissinger again stated, “That’s… that’s not going to happen.”
Tynes said the prosecution was still working on discovery.
A status conference was held on Oct. 15.
A status conference is booked for Jan. 4, 2027, according to court documents, on the witness tampering and stalking charges and the third set of charges (rape, strangulation, and assault).
A final pre-trial hearing is slated for Jan. 4, 2027, on the strangulation, assault, and gun threat charges, with jury selection to be held on Jan. 19, 2027, according to court filings.
Do you have a news tip? Email it to tony.schinella@patch.com. View videos on Tony Schinella's YouTube or Rumble channels. Patch in New Hampshire is now in 227 communities and neighborhoods. Also, follow Patch on Google Discover.
Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.