Restaurants & Bars

Prince Street Pizza Coming To Monmouth Square In Eatontown

What else is coming? Van Leeuwen Ice Cream, Offshore Coffee, Design Within Reach, Pura Vida, STRONG Pilates and Felice fine Italian.

How Kushner envisions Monmouth Square will look when it's completed.
How Kushner envisions Monmouth Square will look when it's completed. (Kushner Companies)

EATONTOWN, NJ — Monmouth Square just got a new tenant: Prince St. Pizza, a famed pizzeria that started in New York City, will open there in spring 2027.

This is their first location in New Jersey.

They did not give a month when they will open, but they will be located at 180 Rt. 35.

Find out what's happening in Long Branch-Eatontownfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Monmouth Square is Kushner Cos.’ $500 million redevelopment of the former Monmouth Mall. Kushner tore down the old mall last year and is in the process of converting it into an open-air town center, surrounded by 1,000 apartments. Monmouth Square is located at the incredibly high-traffic junction of Rts. 35 and 36 in Monmouth County.

A Whole Foods opened there in July, and a CAVA hummus shop in September. What else is coming? A Van Leeuwen Ice Cream, Offshore Coffee, Arhaus, Design Within Reach, Pura Vida and STRONG Pilates. An upscale Tuscan restaurant and wine bar named Felice — pronounced Fell-eet-cHe in Italian and they have locations in Manhattan — is supposed to open at Monmouth Square, too; we're not sure when.

Find out what's happening in Long Branch-Eatontownfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

Prince Street Pizza is known for its Sicilian-style square pies and signature pepperoni-loaded slices. It started in SoHo.

Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.