Crime & Safety

'Bombshell' Clue Found In Case Of Slain NJ Mom, Therapist: Report

New DNA evidence reportedly has led to a development in the unsolved murder.

CHESTER, NJ — New "bombshell" evidence has been unearthed in the five-month-old case of therapist and new mother Brooke Hanlon's murder, according to a report from the Daily Mail.

A former New Jersey police officer told the Daily Mail that detectives discovered DNA that did not belong to either the victim or her husband, Conor Hanlon, 36 (who discovered her body), but have so far been unable to make an identification.

In other words, DNA from a third, unidentified individual was reportedly found in the therapist's Chester home.

Find out what's happening in Mendham-Chesterfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

The ex-cop told the outlet that one of the Chester police officers present at the questioning of Conor Hanlon reported that he acted 'very bizarre' and believed him to be suspicious.

"But they have that third DNA. They can't lock anyone up because of that. You have to give everything up in discovery," the anonymous source told the Daily Mail. "They are trying to run this (third DNA source) down. From what I hear - I don't think they had slam-dunk proof it's him (Conor)."

Nobody, including Conor, has publicly been charged with anything having to do with Brooke's murder, as of Monday afternoon. Conor reportedly hired an attorney within the first month of the June 6 slaying.

Find out what's happening in Mendham-Chesterfor free with the latest updates from Patch.

The source also said that investigators believe the murder weapon, which the outlet says is a knife, is somewhere in the woods off Route 206.

The revelation could be the reason investigators were seen at the Pottersville Road home taking out what appeared to be evidence, some of which reportedly looked like a bed frame, a large picture frame, and a hamper.

More: Investigators Took These Items From Slain NJ Mom's Home, Report Says

If investigators did find a third set of DNA, it would've been run through the FBI's national DNA database to be compared with anyone's DNA in the system. If there was no match, it's likely the mystery third person has never been arrested or processed for a crime.

Patch has reached out to the Morris County Prosecutor's Office, which is leading the investigation, and was not immediatly available. Nearly all of Patch's inquiries of the Brooke Hanlon case so far have been met with "no update at this time" from the prosecutor's office.

Click here to read the Daily Mail's full report.

Previous reporting:

Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.