Politics & Government
Toms River Ordered To Continue Salary Step Increases During Contract Talks
Longevity salary increases halted during negotiations with police dispatchers prompted a complaint to state labor officials.
TOMS RIVER, NJ — Toms River Township has been ordered to resume longevity salary increases to police dispatchers covered by a union while negotiations continue for a new contract.
The Public Employment Relations Commission on Monday upheld an interim order issued in July by Commission Designee James R. Glowacki that said Toms River had to continue the salary step increases.
Toms River officials and the New Jersey Firefighters Mutual Benevolent Association Local No. 483 were negotiating a new contract after the previous contract expired Dec. 31, 2024.
Find out what's happening in Toms Riverfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
According to the interim ruling in July, Toms River had continued to provide step increases for 18 months after the contract expired.
But on May 26, the union president was notified by Toms River Police Chief Guy Maire that the township would halt all salary and longevity increments effective July 1, according to the document.
Find out what's happening in Toms Riverfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
Jeffrey Lunn, president of the union representing the dispatchers, was told by the township's payroll supervisor that "the dispatcher’s union would have step and longevity progression frozen until a new contract is in place."
The town's personnel manager said the contract didn't have "a specific provision for extension of steps past the contract’s end date. Therefore, all steps and increases will be frozen until the new contract is ratified."
The union filed an unfair labor practices complaint alleging the town was failing to negotiate in good faith on the new contract.
Toms River contended the step increases granted in the 18 months between the expiration of the contract and July 1 were a mistake. In addition, the town argued the dispatchers weren't entitled to step increases because they weren't guaranteed to continue after the contract expired.
The ruling in July was an interim order. Toms River asked the commission to revisit the interim order but the commission ruled 6-0 to uphold the interim order.
"FMBA has demonstrated a substantial likelihood of prevailing in a final Commission decision on its legal and factual allegations, because under relevant precedent, a public employer may not unilaterally freeze salary increments during negotiations for a successor agreement, even where the expired CNA was silent regarding continued payment of increments, if there is an established past practice of continued increment payments," the order said. "The New Jersey Supreme Court has held that public employers may not unilaterally alter terms and conditions of employment while parties are actively in negotiations for a new collectively negotiated agreement."
"Such unilateral alterations of the status quo cut against “the importance of maintaining the then-prevailing terms and conditions of employment during this delicate period until the new term and conditions are arrived at by agreement," it said.
The ruling said that the claims the previous step approvals were a mistake were not sufficient to stop it, the Commission said.
"We'll fight that determination," Toms River Mayor Daniel Rodrick said. "You can't move up on a salary guide for a contract that's expired."
He said allowing the salary step increases to proceed sets "a dangerous precedent" for public employers across the state.