Politics & Government
Electric Carriages Could Replace Central Park's Horse-Drawn Rides
Carriage owners and drivers have also filed a federal lawsuit challenging the ban as officials consider alternative rides.
CENTRAL PARK— Even as New York City moves to phase out its horse-drawn carriage industry, two major questions remain: What will replace the rides in Central Park, and will the city’s ban survive a legal challenge?
Mayor Zohran Mamdani has directed his administration to study electric carriages and pedal-assist bicycles as possible alternatives inside Central Park.
Electric carriages could also operate along the park's perimeter, though the city has not settled on a design or operating plan.
Find out what's happening in Central Parkfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
The proposal has drawn objections from the Central Park Conservancy, the nonprofit organization responsible for managing the park.
The group argues motorized vehicles would compete for space with pedestrians, runners and cyclists.
Find out what's happening in Central Parkfor free with the latest updates from Patch.
The conservancy instead favors a regulated, year-round pedicab fleet, according to a spokesperson.
"Reintroducing cars would return it to a more dangerous and unstable past," a spokesperson for the organization wrote in a statement.
Minutes after Mamdani signed the bill, the union representing carriage owners and drivers filed a federal lawsuit in Manhattan. A carriage medallion owner and two drivers also joined the case as plaintiffs.
"This bill is an unconstitutional abomination," Transport Workers Union International President John Samuelsen said.
The lawsuit names Mamdani, the City Council and several city agency officials as defendants.
The complaint challenges the city's plan to take back carriage medallions, some of which owners purchased for hundreds of thousands of dollars, without guaranteeing compensation.
It also disputes restrictions preventing owners and drivers from selling their horses to carriage operators in other cities or states where the rides remain legal.
The legislation, known as Romanch's Law, will prohibit horse-drawn carriage rides on New York City streets beginning June 1, 2028.
Council Member Christopher Marte sponsored the measure in honor of 18-year-old Romanch Mahajan, who died June 16 after a carriage horse bolted in Central Park.
The Mamdani administration estimates approximately 200 people will lose their livelihoods as the industry shuts down, including medallion owners, carriage drivers and stable workers.
The city plans to facilitate medallion buybacks for owners and establish a Horse Carriage Worker Industry Program, which would help affected workers find jobs and create businesses.
Officials expect to release a detailed transition plan by April 2027.
Council Speaker Julie Menin expressed confidence the law would withstand the legal challenge.