Politics & Government

Pause Fairfax’s Flock Cameras Over Privacy Concerns, Sizemore-Heizer Says

Supervisor Rachna Sizemore-Heizer explains her vote against continued use of Flock cameras and calls for a pause in Fairfax County.

Patch requested comments from Fairfax County supervisors who opposed Tuesday’s board matter regarding Flock cameras. The following response from Braddock District Supervisor Rachna Sizemore-Heizer is published verbatim.

At our Tuesday Board meeting, I voted against continuing the County’s use of Flock license plate reader cameras. I have fundamental concerns about how this technology affects our residents’ privacy, civil liberties, and Fourth Amendment protection against unreasonable searches and seizures. I also have concerns about data security, its effectiveness when balanced against the constitutional issues, and the fear it creates in parts of our community. Until those questions are resolved, I believe the County should stop using the cameras while we review them further and engage our community to help determine the best path forward that balances safety with privacy rights.

I appreciate Chairman McKay’s efforts to place further limits on these cameras. I’m also grateful to our Police Department, which proactively put strong protections around this data. There have been no identified instances of misuse by our police. My vote is not a criticism of our officers, whom I trust and respect, or of my colleagues who reached a different decision.

Find out what's happening in Burkefor free with the latest updates from Patch.

These cameras have law enforcement benefits, and our police naturally want every tool that might help solve a crime. Our role as elected officials is different. We swore an oath to support the Constitution, and public safety, civil liberties, and freedom cannot be traded away easily. I have significant concerns about making that trade.

Misuse isn’t the only concern. Unlike a camera focused on a single incident or location, this network automatically records every car that passes, along with the time and place. No one needs to be watching for it to track us. Over time, it builds a searchable record of where residents go: to work, to a doctor, to a place of worship or to a loved one’s home. The privacy concern begins when that data is collected on all of us, most of whom are not suspected of anything.

Find out what's happening in Burkefor free with the latest updates from Patch.

That is why who can access the data, and under what standard, matters so much. The courts increasingly recognize that records of our movements, even in public spaces, are private and require a judge’s approval to access. The warrant requirement is a structural check that dates to our country's founding, not a judgment about any officer’s integrity. It doesn’t stop police from using this data. It means a judge signs off first. The safeguards in this motion are meaningful, but they don’t include that warrant requirement check.

I also have concerns about data security. Flock has drawn national scrutiny over how its data has been accessed and shared elsewhere. Any database like this can be breached, misused or shared further than we intended, and surveillance networks tend to grow over time. I’m also not comfortable with the idea of a regional data-sharing model developed through the Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments. With respect to COG, decisions about who can see where Fairfax residents have been should stay with the County, where residents can hold us accountable.

The stakes are especially high for some of our neighbors, including domestic violence survivors, who could be tracked if this data falls into the wrong hands. They are also high for our immigrant families, who are already afraid to send their children to school or to use services they badly need. When people feel watched, they are less likely to report a crime or ask for help.


RELATED: Fairfax Board Votes 6-4 On Flock Camera Restrictions, Vendor Change


To strike the right balance, we need to know how essential these cameras are to solving crimes, how well the data is protected and who can access it, and whether this network goes too far toward a level of surveillance out of step with our values. This isn’t a partisan issue. Jurisdictions in red and blue states, including Lynchburg here in Virginia, have paused or scaled back their programs. Nearly all of the Braddock residents who have contacted me have asked us to do the same.

When constitutional rights and people’s civil liberties are at stake, we should make sure we are getting it right before we move forward, not after. Stopping the cameras gives us time to decide whether the right balance means stronger safeguards, such as a judicial warrant requirement, or removing the cameras altogether. That work requires more conversations and data and should be done with residents on all sides of this issue, community advocates, legal experts, and our police. I look forward to continuing that conversation with my colleagues and our community.

Answers for the Reporter

1. Why did you vote against the Chairman’s board matter?
I appreciate Chairman McKay’s work to add new limits and the FCPD's efforts to put safeguards in place. I know there have been no identified instances of misuse by our police, whom I trust. But I have fundamental concerns about this technology. These cameras record movements in a searchable database that can be accessed without a judge’s approval. That raises serious questions about privacy, civil liberties and our Fourth Amendment protection against unreasonable searches and seizures. I also have concerns about data security, about who the data could be shared with, and about the fear this creates in parts of our community. Good policing depends on residents trusting that their government will be transparent and respect their rights. When constitutional rights and civil liberties are at stake, we should get it right before we move forward, not after. I think we should stop use of the cameras while we figure out the best path forward that balances safety with privacy rights.

2. Were there specific provisions you opposed, or did you believe the measure did not go far enough?
Mainly, it didn’t go far enough. The biggest gap is that it doesn’t require a judicial warrant to access the data. I’m also not comfortable with the idea of a regional data-sharing model developed through the Council of Governments. Decisions about who can see where Fairfax residents have been should stay with the County. Before we can weigh the benefits against the risks, we need more data on the cameras’ effectiveness, including clearer evidence that the cameras actually drive results. We also need more data-on-data security and on the impact on residents’ privacy rights. And we owe it to our community to engage more broadly, with residents, legal experts and advocates on all sides of this issue.

3. What approach would you prefer the county take?
The County should stop using the cameras while we review the constitutional questions and engage our community. That gives us time to decide whether the right balance means stronger safeguards, such as a judicial warrant requirement, or removing the cameras altogether. That work should include residents on all sides of this issue, community advocates, legal experts and our police. This isn’t a partisan issue. Jurisdictions in red and blue states, including Lynchburg here in Virginia, have paused or scaled back their programs. Nearly all of the Braddock residents who have contacted me have asked us to do the same.

Supervisor Rachna Sizemore Heizer
Braddock District, Fairfax County Board of Supervisors

Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.